rick should have never let her out of his sight,its ricks fault.

Who is at fault is hard to say. He did what he THOUGHT was best. Also anyone who says Sophia got what she deserved is nuts. For all we know she stayed right there and got bit by a walker

We clearly see her run off...

Its sad she is dead....but in a way it got Rick his Balls back.....

Thy Balls of Steel AWAIT YOU.....

And he needed those....Shane is no Leader....he may be able to step up and charge here and there but he aint Rick...

Touché. Still think about when your parents told you something important and you disobeyed when you were twelve. Doesn't mean you deserve to die now does it.


Agreed space mafia. It sucks she died and it was probably the saddest moment in TV for me but hopefully now rick wont take crap from Shane anymore and we can be closer to being done with the loser.

Agreed. Sad that she didn't trust Rick enough to come back, silly girl.

He knows it was his F-up ... thats why he took the situation into his own hands at the end. .........either that or everyone else ran out of bullets from the nuclear strike they laid down. LOLOL

yeah he took it into his own hands AFTER he brought more walkers back and AFTER shane showed him whats up.

It was not his fault about Girl....he went after her....he told her how to get back as he led two walkers away....He did everything he could to search for her while his own trama was going down.

Doing what Hersh wants....well would you? Would you if your wife was about to have a screaming baby thats going to put everyone in harms way? Noise attracts those things and you aint making a baby stay quite.

Shane wants to take and thats just not the right thing to do....



Rick cares about the group and if you were stuck in the woods who would you want the leader to be Rick or Shane?

Rick will come for you....

Shane would say F ya....

I wouldnt need someone to hold my hand bro and I sure as hell would not want some toolbag like rick in my group when he sides with the enemy,HE WAS SAVING WALKERS DUDE,nuff said.

Yeah.. but even Shane was stopped in his tracks by Sophia.

Shane and Rick both have good qualities and bad.. they need to find someone in the middle..like Rambo.

Its not their Farm.....he was doing what Hersh wanted because he is trying to save the groups ass.....

Hitler was a likable fellow at first....then went nuts...

You let Shane lead and it wouldnt be long before it was his way or no way....

Rick cares and he was out there doing what he had to do for the group....

Shane isnt doing anything for the group...


He was so close to to rape with Laurie at CDC.....thats a guy youd follow????

you obviously missed the first part of my post,I would not follow ANYONE but myself,F shane and F rick,in that world you look out for yourself,hell everyone is keeping secrets bro,why the f*ck would I trust my safety with any of them,lead space,dont follow.

The times change people, I think Shane is adapting fine for his survival. If it wasn't for him, god knows of Rick would even have a family. Everyone in the group is making Shane out to be a bad guy, well honestly, the group makes the man. What if Shanes and Ricks rolls where reversed? Do you think Rick could handle it any better? Shane is acting completely within' the norm with the times.

Because in that world thats a time you do stick together.....

Agreed. One man BA wannabees are the ones who get killed first and end up missing a hand. Who the hell wants to become a monster just to survive thats just dumb. There is a difference between living and existing/surviving. I rather LIVE!

No....you dont shoot a man.....not when you both could have made it....

Otis and him could have made it....thats not adapting thats and Ahole....

Rick is handling it better....he isnt leaving anyone behind....

No, wrong. He made a choice, to the point where he thought only one of them could make it. I would shoot the fat guy too if it is to safe my best friends son and my survival. He wasn't like "fuck you fatty" and shoots him, he had a guilty look and said sorry and shot him. Because of Shane, Carl is alive. Thing is, we may never know if they could of both made it, or neither. Shane did the math and went with the high % play.

They both could have made it and if rick knew I doubt rick would be happy....its going to come to blows between them......

Agreed. One man BA wannabees are the ones who get killed first and end up missing a hand. Who the hell wants to become a monster just to survive thats just dumb. There is a difference between living and existing/surviving. I rather LIVE!

Im sorry but I have to say the shane supporters are as delusional as he is and they may like him do to their own lack of morals

I cant wait till they do cuz when they do we wont have to concern ourself with Shane anymore :)

They both couldn't of either. As I said, Shane made the high % play that guaranteed his survival, as well as Carls. He is the only one who is adapting to the times. It is survival of the fittest and he had all the right in the last episode to show Hershal what these walkers really are. Would I fallow Shane over Rick? Probably not, but when shit hits the fan, I want Shane with me, not against me.

Do yall have Zombie Senarios in your head sometimes? Like what the hell you would do if it happened?

Who am I kidding Id grab his nuts too.....




















Thats a joke....

Is your name Laurie or Carl? No? Then hed be against you regardless

Because everyone is against him, the group is honestly making him snap. Whatever damage Shane does to the group is their own fault. It is to the point where I wouldn't be in the group without Shane or Rick. Rick rolls over to much, and Shane doesn't budge. With them both there you have that balance. When there is a horde of zombies infront of me, I want Shane beside me shooting the fuckers in the head. If it comes to leadership and calmness, I would want Rick.