[DogFashionDisco]

So I got my Mad Hatter in the mail today. It arrived with its right foot and right arm broken off, which appeared to happen during shipping. I can't decide what to do about it, because I would have accepted a partial refund and just had someone fix it for me, but the seller said something along the lines of how he "is a modifier and could see someone breaking a figure apart just to have it end up costing them nothing, and fix it himself so he doesn't trust the situation but that doesn't mean he thinks I broke it", which sounds more like he broke it because he figured it didn't sell for enough and this way I'd return it to him for a refund. Plus, he thinks I'm going to pay to have it shipped back to him. I hate situations like this, because I don't want to pay for a broken figure, but I also don't want to give in and actually lose money by returning it.
What do you guys think I should do?