[MUfan97]

Okay guys, my curiosity has been tingling the past few days on this topic, so I want to get a broader perspective here. Since this IS a negative topic, however, let's put down some ground rules:

1: No scale Wars here.

If you like 6 inch, 3.75 inch, or whatever scale you ascribe to, that's fine, but don't rag on a line JUST because it's not in YOUR favorite scale. If it's terrible by the standards of its own scale, though, then it's fair game(also, try to compare it to at least 2 other lines in the same scale when making your judgments. You don't have to say what you're referencing, but just keep it in mind).

2: Outdated or surpassed in quality doesn't mean that it's terrible.

Judge a line from the time it came out, not what came later. This is just to maintain equality in judgement.

3: Just because you like a line doesn't mean that others aren't allowed to dislike it.

If you want to have a valid, friendly discussion about it, and you have legitimate counterpoints, then go on ahead(just keep the discussion as short as possible). If your argument is just, "Well, I like it!" and nothing else, don't even bring it up.

(Also, a line can have good figures, but still be terrible. Judge from the majority, not the minority)

4: No kid oriented lines.

Pretty obvious by the title, but just for extra clarity, do not bring up lines that aren't extremely focused on adult collectors. If you have grievances with a kid's line, that's fine, just don't bring it over here.

5: If possible, have a few figures from the line you're having.

Handling them at a friend's house or something is fine too, just have in-hand experiences with your targets. Personal experience is the best way to judge something, after all.


Alright guys, gals, and the occasional space whale, get to it!