[scottmurdock]

Wade Wilson: Ryan Reynolds: Pass; personality-wise, he's a good fit.
Spider Man: Andrew Garfield: FTW; he looks like Pete!
Green Goblin: Willem Dafoe: Pass
Harry Osborn: James Franco: Fail
Mary Jane Watson: Kirsten Dunst: Fail
Venom: Topher Grace: Expelled
Aunt May: Rosemary Harris: FTW
J Jonah Jameson: JK Simmons: FTW
Doc Ock: Alfred Molina: Pass
Sandman: Tom Church: FTW
Gwen Stacy: Bryce Dallas Howard: FTW; spot-on, my all-time favorite casting move!
Curt Connors: Dylan Baker: Pass
Daredevil: Ben Affleck: Pass; his acting was meh, but he looks like Matt.
Elektra: Jennifer Garner: Pass; save for the black hair, Jen is a believable ass-kicker.
Bullseye: Colin Farrell: Fail; I may have passed him if they had him in the classic costume.
Typhoid: Natassia Malthe: Pass
Kingpin: Michael Clarke Duncan: Pass

And yes, FTW is part of the grading system in UCSC...if I were the Dean, that is.