[boombatty]

Marvel Universe
Best - Taskmaster. Might be reuse, but it reused oh so well
Runner up - Bleeding Edge Iron Man (I think this might be on a lot of folks lists if they hadn't released 8 million Iron Men up to now) and Steve Rodgers.

Worst - Punisher (really, any of them). The first mold was too big and the hands and head were overly large and anime-like. The second mold rehashed the Shield soldier body (which worked for the Shield soldiers) with a horrible head sculpt (and was to small for the Punisher).
Runner up - Reed Richards first figure. Agh! Giant head and Daredevil body = craptacular!

Underrated - The Red/White/Black Hand Ninjas. Very well done Ninja Army Builders.
Runner up - Hydra Agents. Mold may be Daredevil/Union Jack, but it works with the GI Joe harness they added and the paint apps.

Overrated - Nick Fury. Yes it is cool but overrated given that you have to pay out the @ss for one considering it was a MU Subscription figure.
Runner up - The upcoming subscription figure, Doom without mask. Again, demand will be there because it is a subscription but it is a half as good rehashed mold.

Captain America
Best - Bucky Cap.
Runner up - Crossbones (and this was a close one, could swap with Bucky Cap).

Worst - Two pack movie Arctic Cap with Zubas and White "shoot me here" helmet.
Runner up - Arctic Cap with snow board.

Underrated - Ultimate Cap.
Runner up - US Agent.

Overrated - Winter Soldier. Just not that great of a mold. I actually prefer the MU mold, barely. Neither is awesome.
Runner up - Captain Britain, either mold. MU molds (both of them) kick the crap out of the Cap line versions.

Thor
Best - Frost Giants.
Runner up - Destroyers.

Worst - Thor Blaster Armor.
Runner up - Loki with Horns.

Underrated - Fandral.
Runner up - Sif.

Overrated - Heimdall.
Runner up - Hogun the Japanese Norse God.

Iron Man 2
Best - Titanium Man
Runner up - (tie) War Machine 2.0, Mandarin and Armor Whiplash

Worst - Hulk Buster movie version.
Runner up - Action Pack Iron Men with limited articulation and dumb accessories.

Underrated - Iron Man Holographic
Runner up - Crimson Dynamo.

Overrated - Iron Man (movie)
Runner up - War Machine (movie)

Spider Man
Best - Rhino.
Runner up - Shocker.

Worst - Scuba Spider Man.
Runner up - Space Spider Man.

Underrated - Ben Reilly Spider Man.
Runner up - Black Suit Spider Man.

Overrated - Carnage
Runner up - Venom 2

X-Men Origins
Best - Deadpool.
Runner up - Sabertooth (2 pack comic version).

Worst - Wolverine (2 pack comic version with motorcycle).
Runner up - Colossus (with giant hammer and no neck).

Underrated - Gambit.
Runner up - Maverick.

Overrated - Wolverine (Astonishing X-Men Uniform 2 pack with Colossus)
Runner up - Cyclops (cool figure but way overrated)