[Crazy Jetty]

The only thing I have to dispute with what you said, is I do indeed believe that a romulan mining ship would be armed. And again, defensive and offensive weapons are a lot stronger in TNG and beyond, and even what is considered to be a minimally armed ship there could indeed lay waist to a fleet of ships, in the TOS era. So it's really all relative once you put perspective.

I also never disagreed that the science isn't wonky. "Red Matter" drives me insane, and the fact that a TOS era Enterprise (Even redesigned) could make it to Vulcan in a few hours.
It's just of that list of plotholes you cite, most of don't actually exist, if not explained in the movie.

I'm sorry you hate the movie. But I've been a trekkie all my life. I've been to tons of conventions, grew up on TNG, worked two movie premiers in full borg costume, was in more parades than I can remember (in full borg costume), been in two Trek clubs, met several of the actors, and even had dinner with William Shatner.
On top of that, I've also dedicated my life to studying science (Astrophysics, astronomy, and paleontology).
And I happen to think this is the best, and funnest trek movie since IV. And every trek fan I know personally has at least enjoyed it, if not loved it.
I would kill to see it rolled off into it's own series, although they want it for movie franchise.
Either way, it's a hell of a lot better than the shit Brennon Bragga can cough up. And I couldn't be happier that the franchise has been taken away from Rick Burman, who's run it into the ground.