[thetoybox1138]

That's a tough item to sell. People ask anywhere from $20 (for open ones) to $200 (for sealed in box ones), and very few of them are getting that price. If you do a search for the 10th anniversary Elmo on ebay, there are 575 completed auctions (as of this posting). Out of those, only 259 were actually bought - So not even half of them sold. Selling prices ranged from $5 to $20 for open ones, and $20 to $50 for brand new, still in the box ones.

Tickle Me Elmo is just one of those things that has already run its oourse - Much like Beanie Babies, and now there are very few people actually wanting them. As the person above me said, the best place to try your hand is on ebay or Amazon, but you're not going to get much for it - If you can even find someone to buy it at all.