[Dr Kain]

The first Silent Hill movie is excellent. It takes the great plot of the first one, mixes in elements from the games like camera angles and puzzle elements, has the music from the games, and adds a few of its own ideas. The movie is so much like the games that even the ending makes absolutely no sense, just like the ending to the games. THe Silent Hill movie is to the games what Batman Begins is to comic books.

The second movie, on the other hand, is a piece of ****.

As for Silent Hill 2 (game), it is a great game, but 3 is superior to it.