[En Sabah Nerd]

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dr Kain

Scarecrow and Penguin were the best redesigns. Joker, Riddler, and and Mad Hatter were probably the most atrocious redesigns ever. Croc wasn't bad because they made him the right color, but he also seemed to get smaller and lose detail.

OH god have I mentioned how bad the new version of Riddler looked?

That's just it, Croc being gray-skinned made more sense to me. It was strikingly different than his comic appearance and felt more scientifically sound (if there was a crocodile-man mutant it'd be closer to skin tone than green, at least that's how I look at it). I also thought the original voice was better, the second voice was too bland and never really sounded angry.
I wouldn't say Joker's was all that awful, my only big gripe was the lack of the red lips otherwise it was pretty much the same. Prefer the original, but I don't hate the redo.
Mad Hatter and Riddler were just way better in the original. Stupid feckin' pyjama costume Riddler. Mad Hatter got too cartoony being short and giant-headed but losing all color, at least he was still Roddy McDowall.
I really digged making Penguin look like Burgess Meredith's version, creepy preacher Scarecrow was a great new take, and I like the S&M Bane better than the Luchador we got in the original.