[Snowflakian]

One thing you need to keep in mind with the vs. talk outright is that it's never about the character history or skill in question and always about the writer needs of the moment.

Who wins and who loses is always dictated by that because of story needs. Not because of actual character matchups.

Another thing to keep in mind, there is no perfect scenario either. As with any brawl, it can go any direction because of anything that's around or any random happenstance that pops up. And that's supposing that writer needs don't dictate outcomes. Considering the writer is what puts the happenstance in place though, that still comes back to writers dictating it based on needs of the story itself.