[Weapon X]

Quote:

Originally Posted by Gunathar

That movie does not deserve such a deluxe treatment (or that very cool BB-8 figure).

Quoted for truth!

Quote:

Originally Posted by Joe Moore

The 9th highest grossing movie all time worldwide (6th in U.S.) doesn't deserve a deluxe home release?

Nope.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dr Kain

Why? It was a good movie. Not great, but good. It had some wicked battles, defunked some dumb fan theories, and gave us a kick ass Luke Skywalker moment. Just because it wasn't perfect doesn't make it unworthy of getting a good release.

It was not a good movie.

Quote:

Originally Posted by NGW

They could not pay me to own that awful, insulting film.

Insulting is a good word.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Joe Moore

A very, very vocal minority were angry with the film. Box office success like this doesn't just come from people seeing it "just because". The film sustained 3 full outstanding weeks of box office attendance. It's also has solid per theater averages even until last week. That's the type of business you get from repeat viewings.

Not a minority, at least 50% of fans disliked the film. It was very polarizing.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dr Kain

How was it insulting? Because if didn't go the way you wanted it to?



I have never touched KOTOR nor do I have any interest in it. I only care about the movies and TV shows. Everything else is irrelevant to me.



1. I was laughing my ass off at it. Not only because the trolling Poe did was hilarious, but also having the two leads from Ex Machina confronting each other.

2. That was another funny ass scene. THe ending to TFA was so dramatic that just having him toss it like it was garbage was priceless.

3. Agreed.

4. I see nothing wrong with the casino scene. It was interesting to see a casino world in Star Wars as we haven't seen one before.

5. Ray's vision was showing her being on the edge of the dark side.

6. Agreed. Phasma is the Boba Fett of this trilogy.

7. Did the original trilogy boast what Palpatine did to become Emperor? Hell, he wasn't even named dropped in the OT, he was just called The Emperor. Now do I think they could have done more with Snoak? Absolutely. However, the scene where he split was well worth it.

8. lol Yeah, I've got nothing to defend that scene at all. Just awful. It should have been Leia's death scene.

9. Holdo's point was to see how far Poe was willing to go for the cause. I do agree that she should have shared some intell on the situation, but I can see her motivation. Poe was not an official, it is his job to act as instructed and not think. That is the point of a soldier.

10. The battle was just fine. We don't know what Luke did with his green light saber.

What defines a good Star Wars movie though? Star Wars is just The Lord of the Rings in space.

1. it was insulting because it did not respect what Star Wars is about, or the characters that made it what it was. It also took a dump on everything JJ Abrams set up in TFA.

2. I agree about not caring about much of anything besides the films and TV shows.

3. That's why you can't see the problems with this film. You think Stars Wars is LOTR in space. Insulting, incorrect, and foolish. What kind of fan says that? No fan.