[Joe Moore]

Thundercats







Silverhawks

[KingLouie731]

both are excellent cartoons but i had to vote Thundercats HOOOO!

[gunzilla]

Thundercats

[ludovicotek]

This will probably be a landslide victory. Thundercats for me as well. I watched and enjoyed both shows and towlines. The Silverhawks toys were very cool. I loved the vac metal the figures used. In the end, Thundercats just left more of an impression on me. Plus, I had the light up Sword of Thudera that I used to take with me everywhere!!!

[MegaPrime33]

If we are strictly talking toys, then TCats wins out. Show wise though, I think Silverhawks has the upper hand, even though Kenney did both shows.

[scottmurdock]

I love both of these lines and my original vintage figures are displayed prominently in my nerd cave. However, Thundercats had a better assortment of figures and vehicles so they win out...by a hair. That's a tough one!

[trebleshot]

Really tough choice for me, as I liked the toys for both lines a lot. And the shows were decent (Silverhawks was definitely the better show).

Went with Thundercats, since I had their toys first and they had the Thundertank.

[Exodus]

This is a sure win for Thundercats...

[neatogecko]

Yeah...Thundercats all the way on this one.

[Bubba304]

silverhawks were very cool...but thundercats wins for me no doubt about it

[hrothgars]

Watching Thundercats and playing with toys from that Thundercats "universe" was by far and away better, no contest. But the actual toys? I have to say Silverhawks were probably better action figures.

[glass67]

I liked the Silverhawks cartoon, but the toys never did it for me (although the villains were very cool). I never had any Thundercats toys but they definitely had more going for them than Silverhawks. It's kind of sad to see Silverhawks getting stomped on this bad, though!

[Snailbot]

If I had to make a pick based off cartoon, it would be a difficult decision. This is a decision based on toys so I vote Thundercats. Bigger line, better figures, better vehicles, better articulation. Sorry, Hawks.

[Lody666]

Ohhhhh so one sided!

[Crazy Jetty]

I shant vote. I hated Thundercats as a kid. (Still hate the original, and cannot understand why it's so popular. It's even worse than Sunbow's tripe).
Meanwhile, I loved the Silverhawks growing up. Though I can't remember anything about it now.

However, I did not collect either toyline, and wasn't even aware of toys for either until relatively recently. So I have no business voting on toys I don't have any experience with. I will not judge a toyline based on it's fiction.

[Yobuster]

Yeah too one sided. Both were good but Silverhawks was a better cartoon and the toys were cooler with that Vac-metalized plastic.

[Iceman]

Loved Thundercats growing up but I know it doesn't hold up so well. It was cheesy but no worse than what other cartoons were doing in the 80's. Never saw Sliverhawks or knew they had toys. I still remember Lion-O used to drive around in K.I.T.T. because he was the only figure I had that would fit other than Hasselhoff.

[LXL_Guy]

Total massacre here. What a land slide this is turning out to be.

[MegaPrime33]

It's good to see at least a few people voted for Silverhawks. It was a damn good show and the toys were pretty good too, but just not big enough to beat TCats.

[Greylight]

I hate that these two are up against each other! I absolutely loved Thundercats and Silverhawks as a kid, the shows and the toys. Along with Transformers, they were my top three.

My very first action figure was a Silverhawk. But overall, Thundercats was my favorite. This was such a tough choice.

[Power Cosmic]

Easy pick for me. Never was a fan of Silverhawk show - seemed too cheesy even at the time.

The figures are way too generic, unlike TCats with it's wider range of unique character sculpts.